When Self-Criticism Isn’t Your Ally: How to Change the Conversation with Yourself

You know that voice.
The one that notices every flaw.
The one that tells you you’re “not doing enough” before you’ve even had your coffee.

Some days, it’s background noise. Other days, it’s a full-blown commentary track running in your head.

Self-criticism often shows up dressed as “motivation.” It whispers that if you’re harder on yourself, you’ll finally get it together. But here’s the truth I wish someone had told me sooner: self-criticism isn’t your ally—it’s a drill sergeant who never leaves the parade ground.

Today, I want to walk you through how to change the conversation with yourself, so that instead of being pushed by shame, you’re guided by self-respect.

Why We Cling to Self-Criticism

Before we shift it, we have to understand it.
For many of us, self-criticism feels safe because:

  • It gives the illusion of control.

  • It’s familiar—maybe it mirrors how others spoke to us growing up.

  • It pretends to be productive (“If I don’t push myself, I’ll slack off”).

But here’s the thing: while self-criticism can create short bursts of action, it also:

  • Drains your energy.

  • Makes it harder to take risks.

  • Increases stress and procrastination.

  • Keeps you stuck in cycles of all-or-nothing thinking.

It’s like trying to run a marathon while carrying a backpack full of rocks—you can keep going, but at what cost?

Step 1 — Notice the Voice Without Wrestling It

When you hear that inner critic pipe up, the first step isn’t to shut it down—it’s to notice it with curiosity.

“Oh, there’s my ‘not enough’ voice again.”

No judgment. No counter-argument (yet). Just recognition.
When you can name it without fusing to it, you create a little breathing room.

Try this:
For one day, jot down a quick note in your phone or journal whenever the self-critical voice shows up. Don’t analyse it—just record it. You’re building awareness.

Step 2 — Ask: Is This Voice Helping Right Now?

This is where you introduce choice.

When the critic speaks up, ask:

  • Is this helping me take the next kind step forward?

  • If a friend spoke to me this way, would I trust them with my dreams?

Often, you’ll notice that the voice isn’t guiding you toward anything—it’s just looping old fears. That realisation is powerful.

Step 3 — Replace the Critic with a Compassionate Coach

Here’s the thing: you can’t always remove the inner critic, but you can give it a new job description.

Think about how you’d speak to:

  • A friend who’s trying something new.

  • A child who’s learning to ride a bike.

  • A client or colleague you genuinely want to see succeed.

That’s the tone you’re aiming for with yourself.
Gentle, clear, and on your side.

A script to try:
Instead of: “I can’t believe you messed that up.”
Say: “That didn’t go how you wanted—what can we learn from it?”

Instead of: “You’re never going to get this right.”
Say: “This is new. It’s okay to take your time.”

Step 4 — Create a ‘Self-Coaching Pause’ Ritual

This is a small, repeatable action that interrupts self-criticism before it spirals.

Here’s one I use with clients:

  1. Breathe in for four counts.

  2. Say your own name silently (this reactivates self-connection).

  3. Ask: “What do I actually need right now?”

Sometimes the answer will be “take a break.” Sometimes it’s “ask for help.” And sometimes it’s “do the thing, but with kindness.”

Step 5 — Practice, Not Perfection

Changing the conversation with yourself isn’t about never having a critical thought again.
It’s about reducing the critic’s volume and increasing the voice of compassion—until, one day, you realise you’re on the same team as yourself.

A Gentle Invitation

If you’re tired of carrying the weight of constant self-criticism, you don’t have to do this work alone. Together, we can rebuild the way you speak to—and believe in—yourself, so you can move forward without the constant soundtrack of “not enough.”

Book a FREE introductory session with me here.
Let’s walk this path toward kinder self-talk, one step at a time.

Previous
Previous

Radical Rest: Why Doing Less Is Your Most Powerful Next Step

Next
Next

A Gentle Guide for the Overwhelmed ADHD Brain